Rally Thursday February 23 @ PRHC

Nurses at Peterborough Regional Health Centre are holding a rally this Thursday, February 23 from 12 noon to 2 pm. It is one of 35 across the province demanding a better contract from the Ontario Hospital Association (OHA) and the Ford government.

Labour Council will be there – will you? Please join if you are able.

Here is a link that will enable you to send an email of support for the nurses to your MPP, give you the latest news, bargaining basics and some campaign materials https://www.ona.org/bettercare/

See you this Thursday.

As a reminder, later on Thursday, the Peterborough Health Coalition is hosting a Zoom Town Hall starting at 6 pm with Ontario Health Coalition Executive Director Natalie Mehra as one of the keynote speakers.

Register for the town hall here:

https://us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/tZUldumgqTstHdNgoBp_7Nw0NnzEOoNnvjPB

Strategies will be shared about the upcoming massive, province-wide campaign organized by OHC to STOP PRIVATIZATION, and how YOU can become involved.

For further information about the Town Hall, contact

Marion Burton at marionburton@nexicom.net or 705 868-7352

Or Roy Brady at rbrady1@cogeco.ca or 705 745-2446

In solidarity,

Peterborough & District Labour Council

URGENT Emergency Meeting to Fight Back Against the Ford Government’s Privatization of our Public Hospitals

Tuesday January 31 via Zoom, 7 – 8:30 pm

All members, supporters and allies please join this emergency online meeting as we plan to mount a major and urgent fightback against Ford’s initiative to privatize our public hospitals.

Last week, the Ford government announced their plans to build new for-profit surgical/diagnostic hospitals and expand for-profit clinics. At the same time, the Ford government has left our public hospitals with operating rooms that are closed in the evenings, on weekends, for days and months at a time, or even permanently, due to inadequate funding and staffing to run them. Similarly, MRIs and other diagnostics in public hospitals have been limited due to inadequate funding and staffing. Now, after having worsened the staffing crisis in public hospitals and having done nothing to ramp up public hospitals to operate to their capacity, Ford is launching privatization of their core services as if it is a “solution”. It is the old formula: create a crisis and privatize.

The private for-profit clinics that already exist in Ontario and across Canada are ground zero for extra-billing patients thousands of dollars for medically-needed diagnostic tests and surgeries. In addition, they routinely “upsell”, manipulating patients into paying for medically unnecessary add-ons. It is already a very serious problem, and those for-profit clinics only do a small portion of what Ford is planning.

We are deeply concerned. The plan that Ford is now putting into action poses a fatal threat to public medicare in our province and our country. We are going to do everything in our power to stop this privatization.

We have some ideas to mount a fightback that could stop them if we can build it big enough. Please join us.

Tuesday January 31 via Zoom, 7 – 8:30 pm

Please register and fill in the information here (you will receive the Zoom link by email after you register): https://us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/tZApd-upqDksG9PtSt5qAbsgMDZ3VnVAY6Zd

 

What can you do right now?

With our hospitals in crisis and plans to privatize public hospital services are being announced, it is vital that we have a strong show of support to tell the Ford government in no uncertain terms that they do not have a mandate from Ontarians to privatize our public health care. We need to get as many people as possible to scare the Ford government away from their plans to privatize and do nothing to help the crisis in our hospitals.

You can help by:

·       We need to show that those who oppose the privatization of our health care are a major force. Please count yourself in as a “Public Medicare Defender” and get your friends, colleagues and families to do so also. Sign up here: https://www.ontariohealthcoalition.ca/

·        Help educate our communities about the issues. Hand out leaflets in your community, place of worship or work. Printable leaflet is here: https://www.ontariohealthcoalition.ca/wp-content/uploads/Public-Medicare-Defender-Leaflet.pdf (NOTE: this leaflet will be updated tomorrow Jan. 24 to reflect the current announcement and plans of the Ford government).

·        Fill in and share this survey with your seniors’ organization, patient group, community group, friends, family and neighbours to collect evidence on what patients are being charged in private clinics. You can fill it in online here: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSd0SYm3eHDxx2tYPxKOCSmSeeR8jiuqPsUH76Uu3vv8tT2jOQ/viewform?usp=sf_link or the printable version here: https://www.ontariohealthcoalition.ca/wp-content/uploads/final-survey-re-private-clinics-extra-billing.pdf

Enough is Enough Campaign in conjunction with OFL

Many of us have been part of the launch today for the OFL’s launch of the Enough is Enough Campaign!

 

Please go to wesayenough.ca and sign up to this campaign – we will be sharing more information about this important work – but a start is to SIGN UP

 

Here is the link to make it easy https://wesayenough.ca/

 

Please also share on social media and through committees you are part of and / or chair.

 

Thanks all.

Ontario Health Coalition HOSPITAL EMERGENCY Town Hall Meetings

Ontario Health Coalition
HOSPITAL EMERGENCY Town Hall Meetings

Our public hospitals are in an unprecedented crisis
The Ford government has done substantially nothing to help them
Instead they have funnelled millions into for-profit corporations to privatize our public hospital services
CROSS.png
Almost 100 Emergency Departments have had closures across Ontario.
If the Ford government continues to ignore & downplay the staffing crisis
— and use the crisis as an excuse to privatize —
 our community hospitals are at grave risk.
All across Ontario people have banded together for a century or more to build up our local public hospitals. We have volunteered, fundraised and donated from our pay cheques because these are vital services for our communities.  The Ford government’s plan would dismantle our local public hospitals, taking the profitable services out to for-profit corporations, robbing them of desperately needed staff and funding.
We must force the Ford government to address the crisis and take urgent action to support our local PUBLIC hospitals.
We CAN do this, but everyone needs to help to make it happen.
 
Town Hall Meetings Across Ontario
Due to the overwhelming spread of respiratory infections in Ontario, we will hold the meetings online. It is super easy if you’ve never done it!
  • You just need a computer with internet. Register by clicking on the link (called the Zoom link) by your local town hall meeting listed below. The registration form just lets us know how many people are coming.
  • Once you have filled in the registration form Zoom will automatically email you a link for the meeting.  We will send reminders the day before and the day of.
  • When it is time for the meeting to start, click on that link Zoom emails to you and a window will open that puts you into the meeting. You can choose at that point to have your video camera in your computer on or off.
Need help? Email ohc@sympatico.ca and write TOWN HALL HELP in the subject line.

Ottawa

When: Nov 21, 2022 7:00 PM
Register in advance for this meeting:
https://us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/tZUkceuhrDgtGNzvhPL_KI4uWRJgjzvCrTbC 
Perth & Smiths Falls
When: Nov 22, 2022 7:00 PM
Register in advance for this meeting:
https://us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/tZwuf-ugpzkvHNeqQnRp7L6KdI0zWXB01_fT

Chesley
When: Nov 22, 2022 7:00 PM
Register in advance for this meeting:
https://us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/tZYsdeqhqj0tGdUFCj2_g1VaGLlcQZMMetV4
Waterloo
When: Nov 23, 2022 7:00 PM
Register in advance for this meeting:
https://us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/tZctc-iopz4vHtVCy9iQAFcyvN_Fay8rxvsZ
Niagara
When: Nov 24, 2022 7:00 PM
Register in advance for this meeting:
https://us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/tZMrcuuvqz8uHdS5qlGvss3m_Q8Xqw-wK82E
Durham
When: Nov 26, 2022 10:30 AM
Register in advance for this meeting:
https://us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/tZYrcuGqqjsjHtFgd4SZPtePLRrTzcuf_nyU 
Windsor
When: Nov 26, 2022 12:00 PM
Register in advance for this meeting:
https://us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/tZ0sd-GorDMiG9WDLWkExTnDdmBk64JH3dr9
Clinton
When: Nov 28, 2022 07:00 PM
Register in advance for this meeting:
https://us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/tZMrcO6oqT0vHtMUaDoZWyAVpy1lHTYQ8b0V
Kingston
When: Nov 28, 2022 7:00 PM
Register in advance for this meeting:
https://us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/tZwtde2vqDssGtJZc6pWXLorrjIwYwjL4796 
Toronto
When: Nov 29, 2022 7:00 PM
Register in advance for this meeting:
https://us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/tZEqcu2tqjgjE9PHM1p8udav8Y1bRpjWAd7D
Seaforth 
When: Nov 29, 2022 7:00 PM
Register in advance for this meeting:
https://us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/tZ0oc-CspzgrGdLbCy1vCBcXSmkviORi6Cv0
St. Marys
When: Nov 30, 2022 7:00 PM
Register in advance for this meeting:
https://us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/tZcod-mgqTgsE9B4pcddOZWDmABWZt1YqdtX
Hamilton
When: Dec 1, 2022 7:00 PM
Register in advance for this meeting:
https://us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/tZYpc-igpzsjEtJ5T_bmVxiVr6Ko3Ortr8oY 
Town Hall Callouts (2).png

OHC & ACE announces Charter challenge against new law that forces the elderly into LTC against their choice

Good morning,

Please see the information below regarding OHC and ACE’s new law forcing elderly into long-term care homes against their choice.

Ontario Health Coalition & Advocacy Centre for the Elderly will go to court to challenge Ford government’s new law forcing elderly into long-term care homes against their choice: “an egregious violation of their Charter rights”

Watch online here: https://fb.watch/gXqVO4bl8f/

The Ontario Health Coalition and the Advocacy Centre for the Elderly launched a Constitutional Challenge this morning in response to the Ford government’s new law that forces elderly hospital patients into long-term care homes against their choice. The two groups will be co-applicants to the Ontario Superior Court of Justice in what is known as a Charter Challenge, seeking a court ruling to strike down the law as a violation of the fundamental rights of the patients affected under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

On Sunday November 20, regulations under Bill 7, the euphemistically titled More Beds Better Care Act (2022) came into effect, requiring hospitals to charge elderly patients $400 if they refuse to go to a long-term care home or other service against their will. Despite the title given to it by the Ford government, the Act neither provides more beds nor better care. Instead, it affects patients, the vast majority of them elderly, who are called Alternate Level of Care (ALC) patients waiting for long-term care or other services. It enables hospitals and discharge planners to:

·       assess the patient without their consent,

·       share their personal health information to an array of long-term care or other companies without their consent,

·       fill in their applications without their consent, and;

·       admit them into long-term care homes or other services without their consent.

In Southern Ontario patients will be transferred up to 70 km away. In Northern Ontario, patients can be transferred up to 150 km away, or if there are no beds available, any distance. If a patient refuses to go, the hospital is required to charge them $400 per day.

“The purpose of the legislation and mandatory $400 fee is to intimidate and coerce older adults to leave hospital, to any destination, even those which are inappropriate,” said Jane Meadus, lawyer and institutional advocate at the Advocacy Centre for the Elderly (ACE). “Under this law, hospitalized senior’s personal health information can be sent to any long-term care home without their consent, breaching a fundamental right to privacy over health information that every other Ontario citizen enjoys.”

“This law will result in the forced admission of older adults into homes far away from their spouses, whom they may have been married to for 50 or 60 years, making it impossible for them to visit, likely for the rest of their lives, causing unimaginable harm to both,” added lawyer Graham Webb who is the executive director of ACE. “They can now send a hospital patient to a long-term care home that is hours away from their home, resulting in the inability of family or loved ones to visit on a regular basis.  As we saw during the COVID-19 lockdown, this deprivation caused untold harm and suffering to the residents, and Bill 7 will again impose this harm on seniors of this province.”

“Bill 7 represents an unprecedented and egregious deprivation of the Charter rights of many elderly and vulnerable hospital patients in respect of both their right to life, liberty and security of the person and to equality,” recounted Steven Shrybman, lawyer at Golblatt Partners LLP, counsel for the Health Coalition and ACE in the Charter Challenge. “Because the intent of Bill 7 is to coerce certain hospital patients who can no longer be cared for at home into being placed in a long-term care home that may have a terrible record and be far from their family and community, it is a direct affront to the fundamental right to give informed consent to medical treatment.”

“Bill 7 targets a group of people who are vulnerable and frail because of their physical or mental health issues and/or old age, and therefore their right to equality under Section 15 of the Charter,” added Benjamin Piper, lawyer at Goldblatt Partners LLP.

“We have been under enormous pressure from Ontarians in general who are both furious and fearful about being forced into long-term care homes that are far away or that have terrible reputations,” reported Natalie Mehra, executive director. “There is no doubt there is a crisis in our hospitals – a crisis that is the result of government policy choices – choices to fund Ontario’s hospitals at the lowest rate in the country and to have the fewest beds of any province staffed and in operation. Choices not to do what is needed to improve the staffing crisis and build more public long-term care beds as quickly as possible. There are many other solutions to the hospital crisis, but steamrolling over the fundamental rights of the elderly and the dying is not one of them.”

“We are talking about elderly patients in the last months of their lives. They are human beings with the same right to compassion and care as all Ontarians. Their lives have value. They cannot just be shipped off against their will to somewhere they are afraid to go, away from their loved ones, where they will most likely die. It is wrong. We have to challenge this, on principle,” she concluded.

The Ontario Health Coalition has compiled a list of long-term care homes with the longest wait lists and the shortest wait lists in each region of the province to illustrate where patients might be most likely to be forced. Available at: https://www.ontariohealthcoalition.ca/wp-content/uploads/LTC-waitlist-data-final.pdf

 

The Ontario Health Coalition has to raise the funds to cover the costs of the Charter Challenge. To give a sense of the work we need to do, we need to find 500 people who will donate $1000 each, 1000 people who will donate $500 each, or 10,000 people who will donate $50 each or 20,000 people who will donate $25 each. If you can help, please donate here: https://www.ontariohealthcoalition.ca/index.php/donate-now/

Urgent Request: Have you been forced into a LTC home/ faced hospital fees?

Have you been or are you being coerced into a long-term care home or pressured to leave the hospital into community/home care? Are you willing to speak publicly about your experience?
Bill 7 (More Beds, Better Care Act) enables hospitals to assess patients waiting in hospital for long-term care or home/community care without their consent, share their patient information with long-term care homes and other services without their consent, fill in their application to a long-term care home or other care without their consent and admit them into a LTC home/other without their consent. It is an egregious violation of the human rights of the elderly
As of November 20th, patients who refuse to be moved to long-term care homes will be forced to pay $400 per day which is $144,000 per year. Some patients are already being threatened with or are being charged if they remain in the hospital rather than being placed into long-term care, or discharged to somewhere else like a retirement home, or sent home to wait for home/community care. This is pure ageism and ableism and it is being entrenched into our healthcare system.
We urgently request families and/or patients to contact us if:
  • You have been coerced to leave hospital into long-term care/other against your will
  • You have been threatened with charges or forced to pay charges if you do not consent to go to LTC/other against your will.
We are looking for people who are willing to speak about this publicly.
If you or your loved ones have experienced this, please email us at ohc@sympatico.ca with “BILL 7” in the subject line or Facebook message us or DM us on Twitter.
Bill 7 Call Out.png

The Ford government is engaging in unprecedented privatization of our health care services,

The Ford government is engaging in unprecedented privatization of our health care services,
including long-term care, home care, COVID-19 vaccinations, surgeries and diagnostics.
 
If we turn over the ownership and control of our public hospitals to private for-profit clinics, we will lose single-tier Public Medicare.
 
It was regular people that created public health care in Canada and it’s going to be regular people who protect it. Everyone has a role.
Get involved in our upcoming emergency local town hall meetings (click here for more information).
Watch & share our new video below
Click here or on the picture below.
image.jpeg
And please share it across all social media channels. Links can be found below.

New report on the spread of COVID, LTC outbreaks, hospitalizations & deaths raises red flags despite the Ford government’s suppression of COVID Data

Please note the CBC came out with a report yesterday that Ontario had 109 COVID-19 deaths over the past week, which is the highest total since early May.

October 21, 2022

 

New report on the spread of COVID, LTC outbreaks, hospitalizations & deaths raises red flags despite the Ford government’s suppression of COVID Data

 

Toronto – The Ford government has ceased regular reporting on the spread of COVID-19. Public Health no longer publishes daily and weekly epidemiologic reports and it has become steadily more difficult to get accurate numbers. Not only are the government and Public Health not reporting much of the data previously available, they have also cut testing and abandoned trace and isolation measures. Regardless, there is some data available and infectious disease specialists have taken up the challenge of identifying transmission of the virus using wastewater, serology and other evidence. The Ontario Health Coalition released a report today in plain language to give the public a clearer idea of the risks. The data the Coalition found on long-term care and hospital outbreaks, hospitalizations, community spread and deaths should raise red flags. The abandonment of all public protections against the transmission of the virus is resulting in loss of health and death for a significant number of Ontarians.

On December 31, 2021, the Ontario government heavily restricted access to public PCR testing. This meant that a very small percent of the population could get access to PCR testing resulting in a significant underreporting of positive cases.  The end of public testing has ushered in a new era of data suppression in which regular Ontarians had no way of knowing how prevalent and dangerous the spread of COVID-19 was in our communities.

From the week of Oct 2- Oct 8, there were only 66,177 tests done resulting in 8,929 confirmed cases. For context, there were 435,213 tests performed from the week of Dec 26, 2021-Jan 1 2022, the last week prior to the strict rationing of public testing.

COVID spread media release graph.png

Dr. Tara Moriarty of Moriarty Labs, an infectious diseases research laboratory studying blood borne pathogens, and a group of doctors and researchers created COVID-19 Resources Canada in order to provide more information to Canadians. They have used the best available data to calculate the spread of COVID-19 including wastewater surveillance, seroprevalence and in some provinces, self-reporting to give an accurate depiction of COVID-19 in our communities.

Their key findings include:

There were 68,910 new COVID-19 cases in Ontario on October 14, the most recent day reported. That is 68,910 new cases in one day. That is 44 percent of the new daily infections in Canada. (Note: Ontario has 39 percent of Canada’s population but 44 percent of daily new infections on the most recent date reported.)

COVID-19 remains a serious and potentially fatal pathogen:

·        7,235 of those infected on October 14 will have significant symptoms that will last more than 4-weeks and will limit their daily activity.

·        389 Ontarians are predicted to have been hospitalized for COVID-19 on October 14.

·        As of October 14, 1 in 32 Canadians either have COVID-19 or are still suffering from symptoms of COVID-19 and 3.5% of Ontarians have COVID-19 or are still suffering from COVID-19 symptoms.

Long-Term Care COVID-19 Outbreaks Update

On October 12, the Ontario government COVID-19 website reported 152 active outbreaks with 1,526 active resident cases and 480 active staff cases. 11 long-term care residents died from COVID-19 on that date. There are 626 long-term care homes in Ontario, which means that approximately 1 in 4 homes are in outbreak.

Deaths in Ontario’s LTC homes for the previous week:

October 12: 11 deaths

October 11: 1 death

October 10 1 death

October 9: missing data

October 8: 10 deaths

October 7: 4 deaths

October 6: 9 deaths

The Ministry of Long-Term Care statistics have always been lower than Public Health Ontario data (for which they recently stopped reporting detailed breakdowns).  It is evident that they are still underreporting because on October 8, Public Health reported 161 active outbreaks compared to the 152 active outbreaks reported by the provincial government. This may be the last update with reliable information in LTC because as of October 14, the Ministry of Long-Term Care has issued new guidance limiting testing to symptomatic residents, removing the requirement for testing on admission, and changing the definition of an outbreak to two or more residents with a known epi-link.  Staff infections will no longer contribute to an outbreak and homes are now going to be self-reporting their cases.

 

Large Outbreaks in Long-Term Care

Most Public Health Units are not listing the cases and deaths in LTC anymore. In our research we found that only Sarnia-Lambton, Chatham Kent, Southwestern, York, Huron-Perth, Waterloo, Windsor Essex, Peel and North Bay Parry Sound Public Health Units (PHUs) report the number of cases associated with outbreaks.

Sarnia-Lambton:

Marshall Gowland Manor: a 126-bed Long-Term Care home in Sarnia has 40 residents and <5 staff/visitors infected with COVID-19.

Southwestern PHU:

Caressant Care- Bonnie Place: a for-profit 116-bed Long-Term Care home in St Thomas has an active outbreak with 58 cases in their residents/staff.

Elgin Manor-St Thomas: a 90-bed home in St Thomas has an outbreak with 48 confirmed cases and 1 probable case in their residents and staff.

PeopleCare Tavistock: a 100-bed home in Tavistock has an outbreak with 46 confirmed cases in their residents and staff.

Huron Perth:

Queensway Nursing Home: a 60-bed home has an outbreak with 16 residents infected.

 

Greenwood Courts: a non-profit long-term care home with 48 beds has an outbreak with 15 residents and 4 staff members infected.

Windsor-Essex:

Chartwell Royal Oak: a 160-bed home has an outbreak with 20 cases associated

 

The Village of Aspen Lake: a 192-bed home has an outbreak with 19 cases associated.

 

Heron Terrace Long-Term Care: a 140-bed has an outbreak with 34 cases associated.

 

Berkshire Care Centre: a 231-bed home has an outbreak with 18 cases.

Peel:

Extendicare Brampton: a 150-bed home has an outbreak with 55 residents infected.

Waterloo:

Golden Year Long-Term Care: an 88-bed home, has an outbreak with 19 residents and 7 staff infected.

 

The Village at University Gates: a 192-bed home has an outbreak with 43 residents and 9 staff members infected.

 

Barnswallow Place: a 96-bed home has an outbreak with 50 residents and 6 staff infected.

Hospital Update

As of October 20, there are 121 active outbreaks in Ontario’s 141 Hospitals according to the Ontario government. This includes multiple outbreaks in some hospitals.

Local Public Health Unit Updates

COVID-19 Cases in our Communities

 

Toronto– From October 11-18, there have been 1,683 new confirmed cases of COVID-19 and 16 deaths from COVID-19.  70 New cases have resulted in hospitalization.

Southwestern Ontario: As of October 12, there were 238 active confirmed COVID-19 cases, 18 of which have resulted in hospitalization in the Southwestern Public Health Unit

Niagara: As of October 17, there were 823 active confirmed cases in the Niagara Public Health Unit.  There were 15 active outbreaks in Niagara’s long-term care homes, retirement communities and hospitals.

Windsor-Essex: As of October 13, there were 307 new active confirmed cases and 3 COVID-19 deaths, 56 patients hospitalized with COVID-19 and 3 in ICU.  There were 27 active outbreaks in long-term care, hospitals and retirement homes.

Sarnia-Lambton: From October 2- October 8, there have been 112 new cases of COVID-19 and there has been an average of 8 COVID-19 patients hospitalized per day. There were 9 active outbreaks in LTC homes, retirement homes and congregate living settings.

Chatham-Kent: From October 9- October 15 there were 76 new active confirmed cases and 3 active outbreaks in group homes and retirement homes.

Halton: As of October 12, there were 12 active outbreaks in Halton’s hospitals, LTC homes and retirement homes.  On average there are 27.7 new confirmed cases per day and 3 of those cases require hospitalization.

Wellington-Dufferin Guelph:  As of October 19, there were 203 active confirmed COVID-19 cases, 23 patients were hospitalized and 3 are in ICU. There were 4 active outbreaks in the area’s hospitals and retirement homes.

Waterloo: As of October 14, there were 275 active confirmed cases, with 49 hospitalizations, and there were 11 active outbreaks in Waterloo’s congregate care settings, hospitals and long-term care homes.

Huron Perth: As of October 12, there were 4 patients hospitalized with COVID-19. There are 2 active outbreaks in long-term care, 2 in congregate care settings and 5 active outbreaks in retirement homes in Huron Perth.

Haldimand-Norfolk: There are 10 active outbreaks in Haldimand-Norfolk’s long-term care homes, retirement homes, hospitals, congregate living settings and farms.

London-Middlesex:  As of October 17, there were 757 active cases in London-Middlesex and between October 13 and October 17, 4 people have died of COVID-19. There were 18 active outbreaks in LTC homes, hospitals and retirement communities.

Hamilton: As of October 18, there were 141 active confirmed cases in Hamilton. As of October 10, there have been 2 cases requiring hospitalization per day on average and as of October 12, there have been on average 19 active outbreaks per day.

Ottawa: As of October 16, there were 873 active confirmed cases of COVID-19, 36 of which are currently getting treatment in a hospital. There are currently 68 active outbreaks.

Renfrew: As of October 13, there were 125 active confirmed cases with 10 hospitalizations. There are also 7 active outbreaks in Renfrew’s hospitals, long-term care homes and hospitals.

York: As of October 18, 93 people in York region were hospitalized with COVID-19. There were 20 active outbreaks in York’s retirement homes, long-term care homes and hospitals.

Peterborough: As of October 5, there were 489 active confirmed cases in Peterborough, 33 of which are currently being hospitalized for COVID-19. There were 14 active outbreaks in Peterborough’s hospitals, long-term care homes and retirement homes.

Durham: From October 5- October 12, there were 343 new active confirmed COVID-19 cases, 5 patients were hospitalized, 1 patient ended up in ICU and there was 1 death from COVID-19.  There were 21 ongoing outbreaks in Durham’s long-term care homes, retirement homes, and hospitals.

Haliburton, Kawartha, Pine Ridge District: Does not report case data, there are 5 active COVID-19 outbreaks in the area’s congregate care settings, long-term care, retirement homes and hospitals.

Hastings Prince Edward: As of October 18, there were 189 active confirmed cases, 35 of whom are currently hospitalized with COVID-19 and 3 are in ICU. There are 14 active outbreaks in Hastings-Prince Edward’s long-term care, hospitals and retirement homes.

Leeds, Grenville and Lanark:  As of October 18, there were 226 new confirmed cases, 15 people were hospitalized with COVID-19, 5 were in ICU and 1 was on a ventilator. There are 15 active outbreaks with 242 cases associated with them in the area’s hospitals, congregate care and community living facilities.

Kingston Frontenac Lennox & Addington:  As of October 18, there were 415 active confirmed cases, 24 of whom were hospitalized with COVID-19 and 6 were in ICU. There were 11 active outbreaks in KFL&A’s hospitals, long-term care, retirement homes and group homes.

Eastern Ontario: As of October 18, there were 16 people hospitalized for COVID-19, 3 of whom were in ICU.  There were 12 active outbreaks in Eastern Ontario’s facilities.

Simcoe-Muskoka: As of October 13, there were 748 active cases of COVID-19, 23 of whom were hospitalized for COVID-19, and 8 people have died from COVID-19 in the last week. There were 30 outbreaks in the area’s facilities.

Grey-Bruce: As of October 13, there were 89 active confirmed COVID-19 cases, 5 of whom are currently hospitalized with COVID-19.

Northwestern: There are 70 active confirmed COVID-19 cases and 4 active outbreaks in the Northwestern PHU.

Timiskaming: There are 78 active confirmed COVID-19 cases in Timiskaming, 12 of whom are currently hospitalized and 1 is in ICU.  There are 4 active outbreaks in long-term care, retirement homes and hospitals.

North Bay Parry Sound: As of October 12, there were 182 active confirmed cases, 22 of which are currently hospitalized and 4 outbreaks in long-term care, hospitals and retirement homes. North Bay Regional Health Centre has an outbreak with 22 cases associated with it.

Algoma: In the last week there were 215 new active confirmed cases in Algoma, there are 45 people hospitalized with COVID and 5 of them are in the ICU. There are 14 active outbreaks in Algoma’s hospitals, long-term care and retirement homes.

Sudbury: As of October 17, there were 295 active confirmed cases in the Sudbury area, 55 patients are currently hospitalized and 1 is in ICU. There were 14 active outbreaks in Sudbury’s hospitals, retirement homes and long-term care homes.

Porcupine:  As of October 12, there were 8 active outbreaks in the Porcupine PHU’s long-term care, hospitals, congregate care and retirement homes.

Thunder Bay: As of October 13, there were 234 active confirmed COVID-19 cases in Thunder Bay, 57 people were hospitalized for COVID-19 and 1 was in the ICU. There were 10 active outbreaks in Thunder Bay’s long-term care, hospitals, retirement homes and congregate care settings.

Brant County: As of October 18, there were 92 active confirmed cases in Brant County, 7 of whom have been hospitalized. There are 6 active outbreaks in Brant County’s hospitals, retirement homes and long-term care homes.

Peel: From October 14- October 18, there were 195 new active confirmed cases in Peel. On October 18 there were 15 active outbreaks in Peel’s long-term care and retirement homes.

HUGE thank you & quick update on Orchard Villa for-profit license renewal consultation

Dear members and supporters,

Thank you so much to the dozens of people who have sent us your submissions regarding the Orchard Villa long-term care license and thank you to everyone for spreading the word as well. The deadline for submissions was Wednesday. We will now wait and see what the Ford government does and respond when they make their next move. We promise that we will continue our fight to ensure that residents and families are protected and that justice and accountability are finally achieved. Our submission regarding the proposed license can be found below and attached. Thank you all, from the bottom of our hearts, for your work and your commitment. It was really moving to see and read all your submissions. We hope you are proud of our work together. >>>

Submission to Ministry of Long-Term Care Public Consultation on New License & Expansion for Southbridge Care Homes Orchard Villa

 

To:       The Director under the Fixing Long-Term Care Act, 2021

Ministry of Long-Term Care
Capital Planning Branch
438 University Avenue, 8th Floor
Toronto, Ontario M5G 2K8

Via email: LTCHomes.Licensing@ontario.ca

 

From:   Ontario Health Coalition

 

Re:       PROJECT #23-034 Orchard Villa , Southbridge

 

Date:    October 19, 2022

Under Ontario’s long-term care legislation, “A person is only eligible to be issued a license for a long-term care home if… the past conduct relating to the operation of a long-term care home or any other matter or business of the following affords reasonable grounds to believe that the home will be operated in accordance with the law and with honesty and integrity”.

The law sets out eligibility criteria including:

·        that the home and its operation would comply with the legislation and the regulations;

·        that the past conduct relating to the operation of a long-term care home affords reasonable grounds to believe that the home will be operated in accordance with the law and with honesty and integrity;

·        it has been demonstrated that the applicant is competent to operate a long-term care home in a responsible manner;

·        the past conduct relating to the operation of a long-term care home affords reasonable grounds to believe that the home will not be operated in a manner that is prejudicial to the health, safety or welfare of its residents.

 

In light of Southbridge’s appalling record at Orchard Villa, it would be unreasonable and contrary to law for the government to find that Southbridge is eligible to be approved for a new license and expansion at Orchard Villa. No reasonable assessment could conclude that Southbridge is competent to operate Orchard Villa, or that its conduct affords reasonable grounds to believe that the home will be operated with honesty and integrity and not in a manner that is prejudicial to the health, safety or welfare of its residents.

Orchard Villa LTC in Pickering Ontario gained widespread notoriety for its appalling record during the COVID-19 pandemic. At least 206 of Orchard Villa’s 233 residents contracted COVID-19, along with more than 100 staff. At least 70 residents died. Reports from families of residents, the local hospital, the Canadian Forces and repeated inspections before and since the first wave of the pandemic provide hair-raising accounts of failures to provide sound infection control; dire understaffing; inadequate hydration and feeding; uncleanliness; flies and cockroaches; lack of vital supplies and egregious lack of care.

According to a CBC analysis, for-profit LTC chain Southbridge, which owns Orchard Villa, had the worst record among the for-profits during the pandemic with 9 deaths per 100 residents in homes with outbreaks. Orchard Villa had at least 30 deaths per 100 residents.

Not only was Southbridge’s record hair-raising during the first wave of the pandemic, since then, their operating record continues to be extremely poor. In the thirteen months from May 26, 2020 to June 29, 2021, there were fourteen inspections carried out at Orchard Villa.  These inspections resulted in:

  • 45 Written Notifications
  • 26 Voluntary Plans of Corrections
  • 7 Compliance Orders

Many of these are major violations related to keeping residents safe from abuse, failing to follow care plans, lack of PPE, failing to keep equipment in good repair, assessments not being completed after falls, failing to provide assessments for skin breakdowns/wounds, failing to ensure that drugs are not given to residents unless they are prescribed to them, and more

After June 29, 2021, even as the consultation on its new license and expansion has proceeded, Southbridge has continued to receive non-compliance notices at Orchard Villa resulting from inspections for critical incidents, complaints and other inspections as follows:

·        A Written Notification on August 31, 2021 related to a critical incident for a resident fall and injury.

·        3 Written Notifications and 3 Voluntary Plans of Corrections on March 10, 2022 related to falls, poor food, failure to provide PPE to staff and ensure its use for residents with infectious disease, other breaches of infection control protocols.

·        2 Written Notifications and 2 Voluntary Plans of Corrections on March 16, 2022 related to failure to report an allegation of abuse that resulted in an injury to a resident.

·        2 Written Notifications and 1 Compliance Order on June 8, 2022 related to failure to report an allegation of abuse, failure to meet minimum heating temperatures in January, and another fall that resulted in the residents’ death.

Thus, in the most recent year, Orchard Villa has again been found non-compliant repeatedly resulting in escalating enforcement attempts including: another 11 Written Notifications, 5 Voluntary Plans of Corrections and a Compliance Order.

This record of poor care stretches back to when Southbridge bought Orchard Villa from its previous owner, Community Lifecare Inc., in 2015, during what Southbridge’s Chairman has called its “acquisition phase”. Southbridge does not have a history of operating LTC homes. It purchases and licenses homes in order to draw a return on its investment. As it notes on its website, Southbridge hires a management firm, Extendicare Canada Inc., “to manage the operations of our homes, both before and after redevelopment.” Extendicare is a for-profit LTC management company that trades on the TSX. Thus, investors are looking for a return on investment from two layers of Orchard Villa’s operations.

 

Southbridge is currently licensed for 233 long-term care beds at Orchard Villa. That license was initially granted in July 2010 to Community Lifecare Inc. from which Southbridge purchased the home as noted above. Southbridge is now proposing to develop 87 additional long-term care beds “conditionally allocated by the Ministry of Long-Term Care” to be included in the proposed 320-bed development project; and the issuance of a new license with a term of up to 30 years for the operation of 320 new beds at the existing location, following the development.

 

In summary, the record of care provided by Southbridge at Orchard Villa is appalling. Recorded observations by hospital staff, the Canadian Forces, inspections officers include the following:

 

·        Staffing levels at the home to be 20-25% of the normal complement, garbage “everywhere”, “very shocking” personal protective equipment (PPE) practices, and the absence of even rudimentary infection control measures. Just to “stabilize the situation,” Orchard Villa required a deep clean costing almost $500,000.”

Source: Ontario’s Long-Term Care COVID-19 Commission.

 

·        Poor infection control practices, including improper use of PPE; the presence of cockroaches, flies and rotting food; such inadequate resident care that residents were being left in soiled diapers, experienced falls without the post-fall assessments required by regulation, were the victims of medication administration errors, were not properly hydrated or sat up for meals (increasing their choking risk); a broad lack of medical supplies, including limited and/or inaccessible wound care supplies, linens and soaker pads, or properly functioning oxygen generators and suction units; residents being left on mattresses on the floor to prevent them from getting up and walking; significant shortcomings concerning incident reporting and communication between all levels of staff; and lack of training for staff and “[n]o accountability for staff in regards to upholding basic care needs or best practices”.

Source: Canadian Armed Forces.

 

·        Dire understaffing, poor management, and the absence of infection control procedures at the home, conditions that resulted in extreme weight loss, bed sores, infections and other harms.

Source: testimony of Orchard Villa families to Ontario’s Long-Term Care COVID-19 Commission.

 

·        Routine failure to follow falls protocols – even those resulting in injury and death for residents; failure to report abuse resulting in harm; failure to follow infection control protocols; failure to provide PPE to staff and ensure they use it even in recent months; failure to follow care plans and provide safe clinical care; failure to keep equipment in good operating order and to keep the home heated adequately in the winter.

Source: Inspection non-compliance reports, Ministry of Long-Term Care.

 

Given its long-standing record of regulatory non-compliance; its persistent failure to operate the Orchard Villa home in accordance with the law and with honesty; its demonstrable failure to operate Orchard Villa in a competent and responsible manner; and its chronic failure to protect the health, safety and welfare of its residents, the Applicant is clearly not eligible for a license to operate this long-term care home and its application for a license to do so must be denied.

 

Respectfully Submitted By:

 

Natalie Mehra

Executive Director

Ontario Health Coalition

15 Gervais Drive, Suite 201

Toronto, ON M3C 1Y8

ohc@sympatico.ca

 

Ontario Health Coalition Announces Our Highest Awards for 2022

October 21, 2022

 

Ontario Health Coalition Announces Our Highest Awards for 2022:

This year’s recipients have shown extraordinary commitment to safeguarding public health care and advocacy for long-term care residents and their families

 

Toronto – They contributed in unique ways, but each demonstrated extraordinary commitment to the public interest, the Ontario Health Coalition reported as it announced the winners of its highest awards. The awards celebrate the contributions of Ontarians who have made a remarkable contribution in public health care.

“This year we have faced enormous challenges in public health care. Each of our award winners have given extraordinarily of their time and effort in the public interest. They are beacons of hope. It is our honour to have worked with them and supported their efforts,” said Natalie Mehra, executive director of the Ontario Health Coalition.

The Ethel Meade Award awarded to Rabbi Shalom Schachter, Toronto

Ethel Meade was a long-standing advocate on health care issues. She was the Vice Chair of CareWatch (a home care advocacy group), a founder and chair of the Ontario Coalition of Senior Citizens’ Organizations, a founder and co-chair of the Ontario Health Coalition, a member of the Seniors’ Secretariat and the Ontario Association of Social Workers Committee on Issues of Aging, among many others. Her knowledge of the health system was encyclopaedic and she was consulted by governments at the municipal and provincial level, as well as by professional and community organizations, regarding the development of public policy in her areas of particular passion, including home and community care.

The Ethel Meade Award was created upon Ethel’s retirement from the Ontario Health Coalition Board of Directors and is given to the person whose research and/or policy work has made a crucial contribution to the public health care system and the fight to protect it.

The Ontario Health Coalition is pleased to name Rabbi Shalom Schachter as the recipient of the Ethel Meade Award. Shalom is an executive member of the Interfaith Social Reform Alliance Coalition and has had a successful career as a lawyer.  He is active in his faith community and has, for decades, advocated for improving long-term care.  Shalom’s research truly has contributed to advancing the public interest. He calculated the data for a seminal report on death rates in for-profit long-term care homes compared to non-profit and public homes after the first wave of the pandemic for the Ontario Health Coalition. From his work with us, media chains created their own databases and began to track this vital information, resulting in major change in media and public understanding of the impact of privatization in long-term care, and fundamentally changing the dialogue and policy options considered on this issue. Recently he helped calculate hours of care in Ontario’s long-term care homes from survey data across Ontario showing that care levels have not improved despite many promises by the Ford government. Shalom has spent many hours researching, giving advice and support, writing up his findings, helping to educate community groups, faith communities, politicians and others. We are deeply grateful for his exceptional expertise and commitment.

The Daniel Benedict Award awarded to Barb Hogg & Brit Hancock from the Guelph Health Coalition; Linda Mackenzie-Nicholas from the Northumberland Health Coalition; Mary-Jo Nabuurs, Michelle Robidoux & Julie Perl from the Greater Toronto Health Coalition; Jim Stewart and the Waterloo Health Coalition; and Matthew Gventer and Joan Jardin from the Kingston Health Coalition.

Daniel Benedict was awarded the Order of Canada in 1998 for his many contributions for social justice, public health care, justice for seniors, workers’ rights and education, and as a tireless advocate in the cause of international solidarity and global equity. He served as co-chair of the Ontario Health Coalition and was a founding member. He also served on the boards of a number of large seniors’ organizations in which he was a leader in the struggle to safeguard public health care, improve community and long-term care, and stop cuts and privatization. Dan spoke seven languages, had a Doctorate in Economics, and made inspiring contributions to workers’ education in Latin America and in Canada. He is remembered around the globe for his contribution to social justice in America, Latin America and Europe.

The Daniel Benedict Award is given annually to the person or persons who – working with one of the local health coalitions – best embodies Dan Benedict’s spirit of extraordinary community activism and commitment to the protection and extension of Public Medicare.

Barb Hogg and Brit Hancock are the co-chairs of the newly formed Guelph District Health Coalition. They have stepped up and led the fight to protect public health care in their community, building a new regional health coalition, spending hours learning the issues, tirelessly engaging in public education and advocacy, driving across the counties in the region delivering information and public education, attending events, doing outreach and working with local media.  Brit also advances at every opportunity the equity issues impacting persons with disabilities. Barb has a huge sense of community responsibility and compassion, and brings that to all the aspects of her work.  Both of these women have shown truly remarkable commitment to safeguarding and improving health care in their community.

Linda Mackenzie-Nicholas is the chair of the Northumberland Health Coalition.  She has dedicated her whole life to educating and advocating for social change and improved conditions for health care workers and patients. She has helped to stop cuts to local hospital services, and throughout the pandemic has led regional work to improve care and conditions in long-term care. Linda designed and developed a major survey which she organized to have distributed to long-term care staff across Northumberland, Peterborough, the Kawarthas and Haliburton on conditions in long-term care homes. She organized the regional release of a major report based on the surveys, advocating for improved care levels. She has tirelessly led the fightback against the privatization of health care in Northumberland.

Mary-Jo Nabuurs, Julie Perl and Michelle Robidoux are members of the Greater Toronto Health Coalition.  They have organized and attended numerous rallies and protests to improve care in long-term care. Mary-Jo has led movements to mitigate the spread of COVID-19 and protect the public. Michelle has not only done weekly public market tables, developed public education and advocacy materials, and organized people to join in the fight to protect public health care and stop privatization, but she has also been instrumental in advocating for abortion rights, peace and social justice. Julie has been tireless, advocating for her mother and all Ontarians in long-term care to address the care crisis.  She is always there, always exceptionally helpful, engages her family council and others, and speaks out with remarkable courage.

Jim Stewart is the chair of the Kitchener-Waterloo Health Coalition.  He has led community organizing and advocacy to improve public health care and stop privatization. He has inspired and organized dozens of pop up events, organized a truly impressive team of organizers and advocated to stop the privatization of the local hospitals. His hard work, leadership, skills and commitment are truly exceptional and have helped local health coalitions all across Ontario.

Matthew Gventer and Joan Jardin are leaders in the Kingston Health Coalition.  They have hosted events three times a week at busy intersections across Kingston for months. Their commitment to educating and organizing the Kingston community has been unflagging. They have worked to defend public health care, organized public meetings and events on the care crisis in long-term care, helped to conduct local actions, held press conferences and referendums to stop privatization and cuts, wrote articles, conducted public outreach and developed really exceptional public education and advocacy materials.

The Orville Thacker Award awarded to Bonnie Roe, Haliburton Long-Term Care Coalition; Helen Lee, Halton Health Coalition; and Dr Vivian Stamatopoulos, Toronto advocate for the elderly.  

Orville was deeply committed to social issues affecting Canadian families, and in particular, seniors. He was a member of Ontario Health Coalition and a founder and co-chair of Kitchener Waterloo Regional Health Coalition.  He was a veteran, active in the legion, a tireless political campaigner and a stalwart advocate for social justice.

The Orville Thacker award recognizes exceptional commitment and contribution to improving quality public health care for the elderly in Ontario. It is awarded to a person or organization whose voluntary contribution supports the fundamental principles in the Canada Health Act – principles of fairness, equity and compassion – that underlie Public Medicare in Canada.

Bonnie Roe is the chair and founder of the Haliburton Highlands Long-Term Care Coalition and has been a formidable force in protecting public health care and in particular, long-term care residents in her community. She has organized a very active and effective local coalition, met with local politicians, developed petitions garnering thousands of signatures to improve long-term care, organized and attended countless events to highlight the care crisis in long-term care, and much more. Her commitment to her community is truly extraordinary.

Helen Lee was the chair of the Family Council at Mon Sheong and has long been an exceptional advocate for rights for the elderly and long-term care residents. Helen’s grandmother died in long-term care after contracting COVID-19. Helen is active in the Chinese community and has worked tirelessly to educate and spread awareness among the family councils and Chinese community about conditions in long-term care. Helen has helped to organize surveys about conditions of living and care, organized public advocacy events several times per week in Halton, did outreach to family councils and an array of organizations to get them involved. Helen cares deeply about the elderly and about our public health care system and has given of her time, her exceptional talents and her heart to help.

Dr. Vivian Stamatopoulos is an extraordinary advocate for the elderly, particularly in long-term care. In her professional life, she has conducted a major new study on family caregivers. After her grandmother died just prior to the pandemic in long-term care, like the other awardees, Dr. V, as she is affectionately known, became an effective spokesperson calling out the poor conditions of living and care. She is indefatigable, working daily to push issues and pressure politicians. She has organized families and been their voice. Fearless and relentlessly honest, Dr. V’s contribution to the struggle to protect and improve care, and stop privatization, has been truly exceptional.

It is our privilege to recognize these remarkable people. They are heroes in our province and we are proud to work with them.